
Theological comparisons
Key Differences
Read Catholic and Eastern Orthodox accounts side by side. Follow each comparison into its biblical setting, historical development and questions for dialogue.
Compare teachings ↓A closer look
Key Differences
How does each Church understand authority, belief, and worship? Select a topic to read their perspectives alongside one another.
The papacy
Catholic Perspective
As Peter’s successor, the bishop of Rome exercises authority throughout the Church. The bishops together with him also share responsibility for the whole Church.
Eastern Orthodox Perspective
Rome held first place among the ancient sees. Orthodox bishops exercise authority together in synod and reject universal papal jurisdiction over each local church.
Read both accounts in depth
Catholic teaching
Catholics understand the bishop of Rome to succeed Peter in a ministry to the whole Church. He can exercise supreme authority personally. The bishops together with him also exercise supreme authority. Papal infallibility applies when, as shepherd of all the faithful, he definitively proclaims a doctrine of faith or morals for the whole Church.
Eastern Orthodox teaching
Eastern Orthodox Christians recognize that Rome held first place among the ancient sees. They understand primacy within the shared responsibility of bishops meeting in synod. They reject the claims that the pope has immediate jurisdiction over every local church and can define dogma infallibly by virtue of his office.
Historical context
The joint commission at Chieti identified both Rome’s historic first place and differing Eastern and Western interpretations of its basis. Agreement on the ancient order of sees leaves open the question of what authority first place entails.
Sources (4)
- Catholic church documentSecond Vatican Council, Lumen gentium §§22–25
- Orthodox Church in AmericaOrthodox Church in America, Infallibility
- Orthodox Church in AmericaOrthodox Church in America, How the Orthodox Church is organized
- Theological dialogueJoint Catholic–Orthodox Commission, Chieti Document §§15–19
The Filioque and the Holy Spirit
Catholic Perspective
The Latin Creed confesses that the Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son as one principle. Catholic teaching also recognizes the Eastern expression “through the Son.”
Eastern Orthodox Perspective
The received Greek Creed confesses the Spirit’s procession from the Father. The dispute also concerns who may add words to a creed professed by the whole Church.
Read both accounts in depth
Catholic teaching
The Latin Creed says the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father “and the Son” (Filioque). Catholic teaching understands Father and Son to be one principle of the Spirit’s procession. It identifies the Father as the first origin and also recognizes the ancient Eastern way of speaking of the Spirit proceeding from the Father through the Son.
Eastern Orthodox teaching
Eastern Orthodox churches recite the Creed of Constantinople with its confession that the Spirit proceeds from the Father. They distinguish the Spirit’s eternal origin in the Father from the Son’s sending of the Spirit in history. They also object to a regional addition to a creed received by the whole Church.
Historical context
Both traditions worship the Holy Spirit as fully divine. Two questions underlie the dispute: how human language can describe the eternal relations within the Trinity, and who may alter a common liturgical confession. The North American consultation considered each question separately.
Sources (3)
- Catholic church documentCatechism of the Catholic Church §§243–248
- Orthodox Church in AmericaOrthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith: Holy Spirit
- Theological dialogueNorth American Orthodox–Catholic Consultation, The Filioque: A Church-Dividing Issue?
Liturgy and Christian initiation
Catholic Perspective
Eastern Catholic infants traditionally receive Baptism, Chrismation and Communion together. Latin Catholics baptized as infants ordinarily receive Confirmation and first Communion later.
Eastern Orthodox Perspective
Byzantine Orthodox practice brings the newly baptized, including infants, from the font to chrismation and then to Holy Communion.
Read both accounts in depth
Catholic teaching
Catholic adults ordinarily receive Baptism, Confirmation and the Eucharist together at their initiation. In the Roman Rite, a baptized child usually receives Confirmation and first Communion later. Eastern Catholic traditions keep the three mysteries together even for infants.
Eastern Orthodox teaching
In Byzantine Orthodox practice the priest anoints the newly baptized with holy chrism. Infants and adults alike are then brought to Communion. These actions mark the beginning of a life in Christ and participation in the worship of the community.
Historical context
The sequence a visitor sees reflects a liturgical tradition. The Catholic Catechism connects the Eastern sequence with the unity of initiation and the Latin custom of episcopal confirmation with communion through the bishop.
Sources (3)
- Catholic church documentCatechism of the Catholic Church, §1233
- Catholic church documentCatechism of the Catholic Church, §§1290–1292
- Orthodox Church in AmericaOrthodox Church in America, Chrismation
Mary and the Immaculate Conception
Catholic Perspective
Catholics profess that, through the merits of Christ, Mary received a singular grace preserving her from original sin from the first moment of her life.
Eastern Orthodox Perspective
Orthodox Christians venerate Mary as all-holy and as Mother of God. They do not receive the Catholic definition of 1854 as binding dogma.
Read both accounts in depth
Catholic teaching
In 1854 Pius IX defined that God preserved Mary from original sin from the first moment of her conception by a unique grace given in view of Christ’s merits. Catholics thus understand her holiness as a gift of Christ’s redemption.
Eastern Orthodox teaching
Orthodox Christians honour Mary as Theotokos (Mother of God) and all-holy. They celebrate her free response to God’s grace and her place among human beings redeemed by Christ. They do not receive the 1854 Catholic definition as a dogma of their Church.
Historical context
The Immaculate Conception concerns the beginning of Mary’s own life. The virginal conception of Jesus concerns a different event, confessed by both traditions. A shared conviction about Mary’s holiness can coexist with a disagreement about how to describe its beginnings.
Sources (2)
- Catholic church documentCatechism of the Catholic Church §§490–493, 496–497
- Orthodox Church in AmericaOrthodox Church in America, Mary / Prayer / Death
Purgatory and prayer for the departed
Catholic Perspective
Catholic teaching describes a final purification for those who die in God’s friendship and still need purification. The living pray and offer the Eucharist for the departed.
Eastern Orthodox Perspective
The Orthodox Church commends the departed to God in the Divine Liturgy and memorial prayers. It affirms those prayers while declining the Catholic dogmatic formulation of purgatory.
Read both accounts in depth
Catholic teaching
Catholics call the final purification of those who die in God’s friendship purgatory. Their salvation is assured. The Church offers the Eucharist, prayers, and alms on behalf of the dead and understands these acts as assistance to those undergoing purification.
Eastern Orthodox teaching
Orthodox Christians commend the departed to God’s mercy in the Divine Liturgy, at memorial services, and in personal prayer. Orthodox teaching affirms the value of these petitions while declining the Catholic dogmatic formulation of purgatory. Private images of what follows death carry a different weight from the Church’s public prayer.
Historical context
A mourner in either community may ask others to pray for someone who has died. That shared practice provides a point of contact. By itself it does not establish a common account of what the departed experience.
Sources (3)
- Catholic church documentCatechism of the Catholic Church §§1030–1032
- Orthodox Church in AmericaOrthodox Church in America, Essential Orthodox Christian Beliefs, pp. 202–203
- Orthodox Church in AmericaOrthodox Church in America, Prayers for the Departed
Ecclesiology: local churches and communion
Catholic Perspective
A particular church gathers around its bishop. Communion among the bishops and with the bishop of Rome belongs to the Catholic understanding of visible unity.
Eastern Orthodox Perspective
Each local church gathers around a bishop and shares faith and sacramental life with other churches. Synods express the bishops’ responsibility to one another.
Read both accounts in depth
Catholic teaching
A diocese or eparchy is a particular church gathered around a bishop in apostolic succession. Catholics recognize the Church of Christ at work in each such community. Communion among the bishops and with the bishop of Rome belongs to their understanding of visible unity across the whole Church.
Eastern Orthodox teaching
The parish celebrates the Eucharist in communion with its diocesan bishop. Bishops meet in synods, and local Orthodox churches share apostolic faith and sacramental life. An autocephalous church governs its own affairs, including the choice of its primate. Self-government is compatible with belonging to one Church.
Historical context
Ecclesiology asks what makes a community the Church and how communities belong to one another. Both traditions begin with baptism, Eucharist, and a ministry handed on through bishops. Their disagreement over universal primacy affects how each describes full visible communion.
Sources (4)
- Catholic church documentCatechism of the Catholic Church §§832–838
- Orthodox Church in AmericaOrthodox Church in America, Statute, Article XII §1: The parish
- Orthodox Church in AmericaOrthodox Church in America, How the Orthodox Church is organized
- Theological dialogueJoint Catholic–Orthodox Commission, Chieti Document §§8–14
Ecumenical councils
Catholic Perspective
Catholics receive the first seven ecumenical councils and later councils, including Vatican II. The bishops gathered with the pope exercise authority for the whole Church.
Eastern Orthodox Perspective
The first seven councils have a distinctive place in Orthodox teaching. The Church also looks to how a council’s decisions are received in its worship and life.
Read both accounts in depth
Catholic teaching
Catholics receive the first seven ecumenical councils and also recognize later councils, including Vatican II. A council expresses the authority of the bishops gathered with their head, the bishop of Rome. Its decrees receive binding force through the required papal approval, confirmation, and promulgation.
Eastern Orthodox teaching
Eastern Orthodox teaching gives the seven councils from Nicaea I (325) to Nicaea II (787) a distinctive place as ecumenical witnesses to the apostolic faith. It also receives teachings of later synods. Orthodox Christians look to the reception of a council’s teaching in the life of the whole Church.
Historical context
The word ecumenical describes a claim on the whole Church. The question involves more than the number of bishops present. How a council’s teaching is recognized, preserved, and taught matters as much as who gathered for its sessions.
Sources (3)
- Catholic church documentSecond Vatican Council, Lumen gentium §§22, 25
- Catholic church documentCode of Canon Law, canons 337 and 341
- Orthodox Church in AmericaOrthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith: The Councils
Explore the questions in depth
The papacy
What follows from Rome’s first place among the ancient sees? Read the biblical texts and historical practices behind two accounts of universal primacy.
The Filioque and the Holy Spirit
A short phrase in the Creed raises two questions about the eternal life of God and the authority to change a common confession.
Liturgy and Christian initiation
A child’s first Communion can take place at the font or years later. The sequence reveals how different rites express the unity of Christian initiation.
Mary and the Immaculate Conception
Catholics and Orthodox honour Mary as the Mother of God. How do they understand grace at the beginning of her own life?
Purgatory and prayer for the departed
Both traditions intercede for the departed. Explore how their accounts of purification, judgment and hope relate to that shared prayer.
Ecclesiology: local churches and communion
What makes a local community the Church? Compare the roles of the Eucharist, the bishop, and communion with other churches.
Ecumenical councils
How can a gathering of bishops teach the whole Church? Follow the question from Jerusalem and Nicaea to the reception of later councils.
Artwork and usage rights
Local WebP reproduction, cropped to fit the page.