
Theological study
The Filioque and the Holy Spirit
A short phrase in the Creed raises two questions about the eternal life of God and the authority to change a common confession.
Read the guide ↓The two perspectives
Catholic teaching
The Latin Creed says the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father “and the Son” (Filioque). Catholic teaching understands Father and Son to be one principle of the Spirit’s procession. It identifies the Father as the first origin and also recognizes the ancient Eastern way of speaking of the Spirit proceeding from the Father through the Son.
Eastern Orthodox teaching
Eastern Orthodox churches recite the Creed of Constantinople with its confession that the Spirit proceeds from the Father. They distinguish the Spirit’s eternal origin in the Father from the Son’s sending of the Spirit in history. They also object to a regional addition to a creed received by the whole Church.
Both traditions worship the Holy Spirit as fully divine. Two questions underlie the dispute: how human language can describe the eternal relations within the Trinity, and who may alter a common liturgical confession. The North American consultation considered each question separately.
Reading the farewell discourse
In John 15:26 Jesus speaks both of sending the Advocate and of the Spirit proceeding from the Father. The first expression concerns the Spirit’s mission to the disciples. The second became a central text in reflection on the Spirit’s eternal relation to the Father. Both Churches affirm the Spirit’s divinity.
Greek and Latin theologians did not always ask the same question when speaking of procession. An Eastern concern is to safeguard the Father as the personal source within the Trinity. The Latin account seeks to express the eternal communion of Father and Son in the gift of the Spirit.
Who can change a common creed?
A local liturgical development became an issue for the whole Church when a Western form of the creed acquired wider use. Even an agreed translation would leave a second question open. Who has authority to alter words received from an ecumenical council?
In 2003 the North American consultation recommended treating the theological question about the Spirit and the ecclesiological question about the creed separately. Reading its recommendations alongside each tradition’s catechesis helps distinguish proposals for reconciliation from the teachings presently professed.
Artwork and usage rights
Local WebP reproduction, cropped to fit the page.