
Theological study
Ecumenical councils
How can a gathering of bishops teach the whole Church? Follow the question from Jerusalem and Nicaea to the reception of later councils.
Read the guide ↓The two perspectives
Catholic teaching
Catholics receive the first seven ecumenical councils and also recognize later councils, including Vatican II. A council expresses the authority of the bishops gathered with their head, the bishop of Rome. Its decrees receive binding force through the required papal approval, confirmation, and promulgation.
Eastern Orthodox teaching
Eastern Orthodox teaching gives the seven councils from Nicaea I (325) to Nicaea II (787) a distinctive place as ecumenical witnesses to the apostolic faith. It also receives teachings of later synods. Orthodox Christians look to the reception of a council’s teaching in the life of the whole Church.
The word ecumenical describes a claim on the whole Church. The question involves more than the number of bishops present. How a council’s teaching is recognized, preserved, and taught matters as much as who gathered for its sessions.
From a dispute to a common confession
Acts 15 presents deliberation, testimony and the communication of a decision to other churches. Later councils also answered disputes whose consequences reached beyond one community. At Nicaea the bishops used a Greek term for sharing the Father’s divine being to defend how Christians worship Christ.
A creed and a disciplinary canon do different work. One expresses a confession of faith. A canon might regulate the ordering of bishops or a concrete ecclesiastical practice. Reading an ancient council requires identifying which kind of text is before us.
Who receives a council?
The first seven councils provide a common starting point. The later history of reunion shows why agreement at a meeting can leave the churches divided. At Florence most Greek delegates signed the decree of union. The settlement failed to gain lasting reception among the Orthodox.
Today Catholic canon law identifies the bishop of Rome’s part in confirming the decisions of an ecumenical council. Orthodox accounts stress the fidelity of its teaching to apostolic faith as recognized by the Church. Chieti examines earlier patterns of cooperation. It does not supply an agreed procedure for recognizing a future ecumenical council.
Sources and passages (6)
- Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium §§22, 25
- Code of Canon Law, canons 337 and 341
- Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith: The Councils
- Joint Commission, Alexandria (2023), §§1–5
- Joint International Commission for Theological Dialogue, Chieti Document (2016), §§8–21
- North American Orthodox–Catholic Consultation, Steps Towards a Reunited Church (2010), §§2–5
Artwork and usage rights
Local WebP reproduction, cropped to fit the page.