Chapter 7 of 7

A heritage held in common

The first millennium offers Catholics and Eastern Orthodox Christians common witnesses to read together. It also supplies the vocabulary for questions on which they still differ.

Scripture, creed, and Eucharist

Paul’s account of the Lord’s Supper puts the handing on of a received tradition at the heart of community life. Centuries later the Nicene fathers gave Christians a confession of the Son’s relationship to the Father. Those texts remain concrete points of reference for understanding the shared inheritance of East and West. [1] [2] [3]

Two perspectives on communion

The Catholic decree Unitatis redintegratio recognizes the priesthood and Eucharist of the Eastern churches and calls Catholics to study their spiritual heritage. The Orthodox Church in America describes the seven ecumenical councils as authoritative expressions of faith received by the whole Church. Reading these accounts side by side shows what each community emphasizes when it describes continuity with the early Church. [3] [4]

An open historical question

The joint commission at Chieti examined primacy (the place of a first bishop) alongside synodality (bishops deliberating together). It records Rome’s first place in the ancient order of sees and differing Eastern and Western understandings of its basis. This dialogue text offers common ground for study while Catholics and Eastern Orthodox remain outside full communion with one another. [5] [3]

Sources and further reading

  1. 1 Corinthians 11:17–34 · The Lord’s Supper
  2. Nicaea I · Creed of 325
  3. Second Vatican Council, Unitatis redintegratio, §§14–17 · Catholic teaching
  4. Orthodox Church in America, The Councils · Orthodox catechesis
  5. Joint International Commission for Theological Dialogue, Chieti Document (2016), §§8–21